ForeverMissed
Large image
This website was created in memory of Bobby Kelly. We're going to miss him a ton.

A memorial service will be held on June 10th at 2:30 pm at The Center, 208 West 13th Street, Room 101. Everyone is welcome to come share memories or thoughts of Bobby.

In lieu of gifts, please consider making a donation to PETAAnimal Welfare InstituteWildlife in CrisisGrey 2K USA or an animal protection organization of your choice.
June 11, 2023
June 11, 2023
Both in speech and writing, Bobby was an authentic wit. Like the best, he didn’t have an ounce of self-consciousness and never strained for effect. He saw the world through a unique perspective and lightened its complexity and dark moments for all around him, a kindness that did not stop giving. It was a pleasure to be his colleague and his friend.
June 10, 2023
June 10, 2023
Scrolling through 15+ years of emails between Bobby and me, I was struck by, in addition to his always-present great wit, his warmth and kindness and love. He always made me feel truly loved, and I was and always will be deeply grateful for that gift. No one like him. The loss is profound.
March 17, 2023
March 17, 2023
I met Bob in 1971 or 1972 at my first job at Appleton Century Croft. I felt an immediate connection with him and I think he felt the same about me. There is no one that I know who had as much deadpan humor and hysterical comedic speech as Bob had. I still laugh out loud when I think of some of his lines.
Bob was a witness at my wedding and Bob and Bruce honored me by asking me to be a witness at their wedding. I will always miss this sweet yet caustic wonderful man.
March 27, 2023
March 27, 2023
Bobby was one of those special people who you meet in life and remember always. He was singular -- hysterically funny, witty, kind, thoughtful, and sharp. He was truly one of my favorite humans ever.
March 20, 2023
March 20, 2023
Bobby was a beloved member of our Child magazine family. His smile and deadpan humor are unforgettable, and so are his heart and brilliant editorial sensibility. He never drew attention to himself—he would cringe at the idea of being the center of attention—but in his quiet, unassuming way he was central to the DNA that bonded our staff. We loved his sarcasm on staff birthday cards because his spirit was as generous as his comments were hilariously insulting. Bobby made every page in the magazine shine. Copyeditors are unsung heroes. Readers only notice their work when it’s sloppy and mistakes appear in print. But, at Child, every editor could rely on Bobby for making their copy better. He was thoughtful and caring about content, collaborative with colleagues, and a unique, wonderful, and unforgettable human being.
Wayne Jones
March 20, 2023
March 20, 2023
How is it possible to replace the sharp, irreverent wit, the hilarious zingers that were so understated, the laughter, the love, the quiet intellect, the incredible being that was Bobby? It's impossible. He is irreplaceable. My heart is broken. I never thanked him for introducing me to The New York Times crossword puzzle many, many years ago and mentoring me through the learning process. Thank you Bobby for adding so much to my life. You left way too soon.
March 20, 2023
March 20, 2023
Thank you Bobby for your kindnesses throughout the years. Whenever I'd see you, you'd make sure I was not only just tickled by your wit, but also comforted and warmed. This feeling stays with me when I think of you today.

Our condolences to Bruce, and all those close to Bobby. We will miss our neighbor dearly.

From Bobby's friends on the 5th floor, Claire & Peter
Ann Fitch
March 21, 2023
March 21, 2023
I loved Bobby from the moment I met him. I don't remember exactly where or when that was, but I do remember thinking, this person is perfect for my brother. He's smart, funny, cute, and unlike anyone else.

Bobby was one of those rare people who always got it right. He had strong views on everything, and lucky you if you were sharp enough to get his humor, catch all his references. You wanted to be chosen to be on Team Bobby, even if that meant occasional hard teasing and an honest appraisal of how good you were looking for your age. (He was, however, very generous with skincare tips). Vain only about his nose and his feet, both beautiful, he was always hardest on himself.

Animals and children loved Bobby. Like the Pied Piper, our children would have followed him anywhere. They loved it when he'd suggest something slightly scandalous, or console them for having such ridiculous parents. He accepted their adoration naturally, as his due.

He was loved by so many, but Bobby saved his biggest love for Bruce. They met young and grew up together, creating a family that included many pets, great friends, and assorted relatives. They gave each other the space to be themselves. But they were always closely bound, and each other’s best friends and strongest support.

On my last call with Bobby he suggested that I watch "Now, Voyager" and quoted the last line from memory: "Don't let's ask for the moon. We have the stars!"

Bobby might now be both voyager and one of the brightest stars.
May 31, 2023
May 31, 2023
I meant to write sooner. A lot sooner. There's not a day that goes by I don't think of Bobby. The day I first met him is still clear in my mind. Bruce, Jackie, and I were living together in Brooklyn. Bruce had started working at CCI and pretty soon afterward announced he met someone, and they were a couple. Sooner after that, Bruce made arrangements for Bobby to come over and meet me and Jackie. On the fateful day, Jackie and I sat on the rattan coach that creaked with every movement. We smoked and waited and speculated. We were nervous because Bobby was (ahem) older than us. A whopping 37 years old or something like that. Would he think us silly? stupid? Anyway, Bruce and Bobby finally arrived. I remember Bobby walking down that long hallway, not rushing, with a half smile on his face that was partly shy, partly devilish. Within maybe 10 minutes we were all happily gabbing and laughing, forging friendships with Bobby that lasted forever. In fact, my predominant memory of Bobby will always be the greeting: Countless visits at the apartment on 16th street and watching him get up from the couch and walk toward me—that same slow walk and the same shy, devilish smile.
March 15
March 15
Rereading these tributes to Bobby has brought tears to my eyes once again. How loved he was and always will be.
March 12
March 12
I was going to write that it's been a whole year without your presence, Bobby. But, as my mother's tombstone reads, "No voice is ever wholly lost." You're alive in all of us and very present. We have to get used to the new format. Is the above optimism or denial? Tomato/Tomahto. Love to you from this mundane sphere to you, wherever your spirit is now.
March 11
March 11
So many times over the past year, I’ve wondered “What would Bobby have to say about that?” I miss his intelligence, originality, and snark. ❤️
March 11
March 11
We miss you, Bobby. On our minds and in our hearts, today and always. So loved by so many.
March 11
March 11
This year without Bobby has shown us how much he brought to our lives. Still brings. Brilliant and unique, we quote Bobby lines the way he quoted lines from movies. His are every bit as sharp, funny and, obviously, memorable. Betty Davis said: if everybody likes you, you're pretty dull. But everybody loved Bobby and he was many things, but dull is not one of them.
I miss you, sweet Bobby.
August 31, 2023
August 31, 2023
Today is Bobby's birthday. Thinking of him far out there in the universe.
June 9, 2023
June 9, 2023
I first met Bobby at the Scholastic headquarters in Soho, in the summer of 1996. I had just started a job as an editor in the early childhood division and saw him saunter by my office, long-haired and cool-looking. I introduced myself to him and that was that—the start of a professional collaboration that soon became a treasured friendship.

Professionally, he was the best copy editor I'd ever worked with. He still is. He was brilliant—exacting yet flexible, with a perfect ear for language. He could read my mind, it seemed. He made everything better. He made me better.

Personally, there was no one else like him. His combination of intelligence, talent, warmth, and wit caused me to refer to him as "my beloved BK," starting at Scholastic and continuing when I recruited him to Child magazine, where I'd taken a job four years later. Thank goodness the copy editor who was working there when I arrived was such a mismatch that the door for Bobby opened immediately. I'm not the only one grateful for that, as our editor-in-chief Miriam Arond and our many colleagues who quickly grew fond of him can attest.

Oh, the conversations we had in my offices! He listened well and without judgment, gave sound advice, and told the best stories. I can still hear his imitation of his Uncle Andre in France. He made me laugh, yes, but it was the soft core and kindness underneath that made me love him.

Outside the office, he came to dinner in my tiny Park Slope apartment shortly after I got married and walked in with Bruce, carrying freshly planted herbs. They came to visit after my son Truman was born. When we bought a house in Westchester, Bobby took the train to Larchmont and spent a day advising me on the garden, accompanying me to the nursery, and helping me plant. Many of the plants we bought that day are still thriving. A large round terra cotta planter he gave me as a gift—and the rectangular one that held the herbs—sit on my front steps. When Truman turned 3, I threw a "Beastly Feast" party centered on Bruce's first children's book. The mosquitoes brought burritos, the parrots brought carrots, the author read to the children, and Bobby was there too, good-naturedly wisecracking the entire day. When we no longer worked together, Truman and I met him for lunch at coffee shops—not diners—in the city. I will treasure these memories and many more.

Bobby adored Bruce. Their relationship was and is a marvel to me. It grounded him in his life and gave him so much strength and joy. My heart breaks for him, the Fitch and Goldstone families, and his many, many friends.

I am grateful to have known Bobby—to have listened to him, laughed with him, and loved him. I always will.
Richard Sime
April 22, 2023
April 22, 2023
I met Bobby in 1986, or maybe it was 1987, at CCI when I replaced Sal as the Copy Chief. We were office mates & as I settled in I was immediately aware of the man's sweet-voiced wickedness, his uncanny ear for voices & mannerisms, and the great thrill he got from sharing those talents with the rest of us.

I fondly remember when Bobby & Bruce had settled into Hastings-on-Hudson & some of us traipsed up there for a party they were throwing, it seemed like such an adventure. In fact, life for Bobby & Bruce was an adventure! Oh, Bobby, you were & still are unique! My condolences to Bruce & bravo to the two of you for the long years of your relationship.
Mark Schafer
April 11, 2023
April 11, 2023
I met Bobby when I started work at Curriculum Concepts, Inc, in 1985, fresh out of college. I only worked in that office for two years, but still, when I look at his face in the photo, he makes me smile and feel good. Thank you, Bobby, for being you in this world. And thank you Bruce, for loving him.
March 19, 2023
March 19, 2023
I did not know Bobby that well, but I considered him a friend. I believe that came from enjoying every chance meeting I ever had with him. We were citizens of 16th Street and those encounters with Bobby, and others, is what I always loved about 16th Street. Good people always made for good neighbors; Bobby will truly be missed.
March 19, 2023
March 19, 2023
I didn't know Bobby that well, despite the fact that we lived on the same block for 20 years. I'd run into him from time to time, and we'd exchange pleasantries. I will remember his wry smile the most, as if he were happy to see me but also thinking of something clever to say and brighten up my day. I always had the temptation to hug him, but I restrained myself. So sorry to realize that I still owe Bobby a million hugs.
March 17, 2023
March 17, 2023
I think of Bobby and I immediately smile. Then one of the very many quick-witted comments he has shared with me comes to mind and I can’t help but let out a hearty chuckle. Bobby will be missed by many. Alex and I send our deepest condolences to Bruce and family.
March 16, 2023
March 16, 2023
I'd met Bobby earlier but ... clearly...had not had alot of contact when he came through the line at my wedding and said "Hi Austin"..... my name is Scott! Needless to say this had quite a shelf life but it ended being one of those remembered things that showed Bobby's great ability to laugh at himself and that beautiful smile! Too soon away but never to leave.
March 14, 2023
March 14, 2023
My memories of Bobby go back almost 40 years. He was a sweet, kind, gentle person with a quick wit. My deepest condolences to Bruce, Bobby's family, and his close friends.
RIP Bobby

Leave a Tribute

Light a Candle
Lay a Flower
Leave a Note
 
Recent Tributes
March 15
March 15
Rereading these tributes to Bobby has brought tears to my eyes once again. How loved he was and always will be.
March 12
March 12
I was going to write that it's been a whole year without your presence, Bobby. But, as my mother's tombstone reads, "No voice is ever wholly lost." You're alive in all of us and very present. We have to get used to the new format. Is the above optimism or denial? Tomato/Tomahto. Love to you from this mundane sphere to you, wherever your spirit is now.
March 11
March 11
So many times over the past year, I’ve wondered “What would Bobby have to say about that?” I miss his intelligence, originality, and snark. ❤️
His Life
March 14, 2023
Bobby Kelly was a gentle spirit within a caustic case. A word surgeon with a gift for improvised gut-punch zingers. An irreverent ex-altar boy, too. He was an artist, copy editor, B-movie encyclopedia, and—according to many—the funniest person you’d ever meet.

Robert James Kelly was Brooklyn-born along with his twin, Frankie. They grew up in Cooper Park Houses along the Williamsburg/Greenpoint border. Saturday matinees at the neighborhood movie houses ignited his lifelong love of movies, from The Monster That Challenged the World to The Ten Commandments. A bit later, he saw that the Catholic Church had rated And God Created Woman with a giant C for Condemned. He knew which side he was on, and Brigitte Bardot became his actress/icon.

After graduating from Bishop Loughlin Memorial High School, he attended The Cooper Union, where he studied art with many inspiring teachers, including Diane Arbus. He went on to create striking drawings, paintings, embroideries, and eventually collage boxes. His odes ranged from droll to sacrilegious to sexy to disturbing.

After his schooling, Bobby worked in art prep and layout before settling into his career as a copy editor. Neither a stick-in-the-mud language nag nor a frustrated editor/writer, Bobby was simply your go-to, best bet when you had text to be polished. His style was accurate, clean, and elegant. He improved content at Appleton-Century-Crofts, Ideal Publishing, Curriculum Concepts Inc., Macmillan Publishing, Scholastic Inc., Holt, Rinehart & Winston, Child Magazine, and Triumph Learning.

Wherever he worked, Bobby proved the value of playing hard to get. His natural reticence only made him more lovable. His work ethic was strong, yet he never took things too seriously. His spontaneous humor livened up every team he was on. Editors sometimes saved his flags, where he often added a quip with a query.

Now about that wit: If you knew Bobby, you might want to praise his sly wit. Don’t do it. He hated the word sly. “Wit is wit,” he’d explain, red pencil in hand. “Sly doesn’t add anything.” Empty verbiage didn’t stand a chance around him.

There’s no point trying to reproduce his deadpan tone and rapid comebacks here, but chances are good that if you’re reading this, you knew Bobby and can remember them. Please think back to some of the times he made you laugh, and then think about how many of those times there were. 

He met Bruce Goldstone in 1984 and they moved in together two years later. They shared homes in Greenwich Village, in Hastings-on-Hudson, and for 29 years in Chelsea. They raised 3.5 dogs: Cash, Aggie, Mimo, and Jasper (Mimo couldn’t hack NYC, so found calmer fields in Vermont.) 

Bobby loved animals so, so much. In addition to the dogs, he cared for several cats, many parakeets, fish, snails, and a turtle. He was also an inclusive gardener, making room in his realm for weeds along with roses and sparrows. The resulting mix was always more beautiful for Bobby’s open-heartedness.

When his nieces Amelia, Claire, Eleanor, and Melanie came along, he welcomed them as new friends. He never filtered his thoughts or words, so why start with kids? Like everyone else, they were drawn to his cheeky good cheer. 

Bobby leaves behind his husband Bruce Goldstone, in-laws Ann and Stona Fitch, Rob Goldstone and Katy Börner; and nieces Amelia and Claire Fitch, and Melanie and Eleanor Börner-Goldstone.

He was a great guy to have around.


*****


A memorial service will be held on June 10th at 2:30 pm at The Center, 208 West 13th Street, Room 101. Everyone is welcome to come share memories or thoughts of Bobby.

In lieu of gifts, please consider making a donation to PETAAnimal Welfare InstituteWildlife in CrisisGrey 2K USA or an animal protection organization of your choice.
Recent stories

Office Memo

June 11, 2023
Bobby wrote this while he was working at Child Magazine.


From: Robert Kelly

Sent: Monday, March 8, 2004

Subject: My Day



9:30       Arrived; settled in

9:45       Checked office e-mail

9:50       Checked home e-mail

9:55       Went to CNN for latest news

10:00     Cigarette

10:10     Helped Polly with wall

10:30     Rested from wall

10:40     Went to Ebay; searched for “Vintage end table”

10:55     Switched search to “Retro end table”

11:05     Cigarette

11:15     Widened original search to “Vintage table”, many entries

11:35     Widened other search to “Retro table”, also many entries

12:05     Cigarette

12:15     Debated calling a friend; too tired

12:20     Stared

12:25     Went online to “DataLounge,” a celebrity gossip board

12:45     Went out to lunch

1:00       Brought back lunch; rested from trip

1:15       Ate

1:30       Cigarette

1:40       Checked home e-mail to see if anything new since morning

1:50       Copyedited “The Child Challenge”; read twice to “really nail it”

2:30       Cigarette

2:40       Did second-pass copyedit of “What I Wish”; resentful at being “swamped”

3:00       Checked DataLounge to see if anything new since morning

3:10       Checked CNN to see if anything new since morning

3:10       Met with Polly to go over status

3:35       Rested from status meeting

3:40       Cigarette

3:50       Discovered I hadn’t enclosed red folder when I passed Child Challenge on to Andrea

3:52       Went to Andrea’s office with red folder; door closed

3:53       Thought about slipping red folder under door; decided against

3:54       Pouted about Andrea’s door being closed

4:00       Cigarette

4:10       Began to wind down from week

4:15       Decided to chance trying to give red folder to Andrea again; luckily door open

4:16       Discovered Andrea already had a red folder for story; very confused

4:17       Rested from confusing episode

4:25       Returned to winding down

4:30       Listened to funny story from Clover

4:35       Got peanuts from vending machine

4:40       Got water from cooler (thirsty from peanuts)

4:50       Polly left

4:51       Bobby left



Brightest Beltane Blessings

May 1, 2023
Today is May 1st. Wiccans believe that the veil between the worlds is thin and permeable today and on October 31st. That meansthat the departed can mingle with us, if they choose to. The ritual detritus (ashes, soil from the plant Bobby gave me a very long time ago, and rose petals) have been buried in the original plant soil. I invited Bobby to visit and asked him to bless all our gardens as he did in life. And then, of course, he will return to the other side. If you feel especially loved and held today, maybe he is the source. Or maybe he’s laughing. For sure, he is ever more alive in all of our hearts each day that passes. Merry meet. Merry part. Merry meet again.
March 21, 2023
It’s an enormous gift that I have lived my whole life knowing of Bobby Kelly. The whole world has always been shaped (I’m so grateful) by his presence to me- I remember seeing his art and hearing him talk about making things as a kid was one of the first things that made me want to start creating. He showed me how to be playful with art, how to live creatively, how cool bleached hair could look, how to appreciate birds and fish, how to approach the world with a sort of quiet laugh. I feel so lucky that I always looked forward to family gatherings for the promise of seeing uncles B & B, just the most wonderful and joyful couple- being around them was like getting thrown into a fascinating, exciting beautiful, and incredibly fun world. The effect that Bobby had on the whole family can't be overstated. The way he would talk about things (a movie, a pet, a person, a meal, anything ) always seemed so perfectly perceptively discerning, like his impressions always got to the real truth of a matter. He always drew me in with his calm and hushed demeanor, spending most of a family gathering much quieter than the rest of us, and then coming in with the most hilarious one liners. When I would catch him making a joke or funny observation under his breath I felt so lucky. A true master of ‘less is more’! I always looked up to uncle Bobby and always will, there are so many lessons to learn from the way he landed in the world and the atmospheres he drew together out of his delightful presence.

Invite others to Bobby's website:

Invite by email

Post to your timeline