ForeverMissed
Large image
Happy 52nd Birthday Colleen...

JUST BECAUSE     

Just because we laugh and smile
Does not mean we forget for a while

Just because we hide the pain
Still it is and always will remain

Just because she is somewhere in the air
We hope she is listening to our prayer

Fifty years of always caring
Fifty years of always sharing

Fifty years- a gift from above
Fifty years of unselfish love

Recall the joy she always found
In simple living-enjoying sight and sound

She would frown and shake her head
If we constantly were filled with dread

Embrace each moment though changed by fate
Bittersweet, yet celebrate

Life goes on, memories -close like a finger
Warming the heart as they linger

Her life still glows in God’s communion
Our hope is in that joyful reunion

Just because we laugh and smile
Loving her still, all the while

— Love, Dad

*          *          *          *          *          *
A 2019 birthday note from Dan...

As many of you know, Colleen's birthday is on the 28th of November. The 28th falls on Thanksgiving day this year and it also fell on Thanksgiving day in 1968--the year that "our precious little girl" was born. I use the phrase "our precious little girl" because it's the term that Dianne and T often use to refer to Colleen. I think about that a lot, it's so fitting and means so much to me.

Colleen's October 12th services in Buffalo were beautiful. Shortly thereafter, the majority of her ashes were interred in a McMahon/Prorok family plot in Nativity Cemetery in Orchard Park, NY. If you are ever in the Buffalo area, please visit our precious little girl. 

The Monday after, I got a call from the Broward County Medical Examiner. With utmost professionalism, he informed me that Colleen's official cause of death was ruled as  "Undetermined". Her body had no lethal injuries and, more importantly, toxicology showed no alcohol or unprescribed medications. Finding no alcohol in her blood is such a victory for Colleen, a victory she will have forever. She finished her life on this earth with 14 months of sobriety. 

I'll leave you with a birthday gift from Colleen (we all know she loved giving gifts). It's a poem by Mary Oliver and was one of Colleen's favorites. It so eloquently distills the essence of our precious little girl. 

PERCY, WAITING FOR RICKY 

Your friend is coming, I say 
to Percy and name a name 

and he runs to the door, his 
wide mouth in its laugh-shape, 

and waves, since he has one, his tail. 
Emerson, I am trying to live, 

as you said we must, the examined life. 
But there are days I wish 

there was less in my head to examine, 
not to speak of the busy heart. How 

would it be to be Percy, I wonder, not 
thinking, not weighing anything, just running forward. 

*          *          *          *          *          *
Colleen loved and was loved. She was exuberant in life and persevered through many challenges. She loved her parents Dianne and Terry, and brothers and sister, Kevin, Tim and Erin. She was a wonderful mother to Jack and Emma. She and Dan married in 1990 and loved each other and grew so much together. Her caring attitude extended beyond people to animals. She raised her Rhodesian Ridgebacks from puppies and--today--when we say the word "Mommy?" to them, they cock their heads, whine and look to the front door. There wasn't a stray dog on the highway she didn't want to take home and one instance she did (Sugar). 

Colleen had so many friends who helped her through the most-difficult times of her life. She was constantly grateful for that. Emma, Jack and Dan are also so thankful for the kindness and support.

When you walked in the room, you knew she was there. Her personality was magnetic and infectious. A smile and hug from her lasted the entire day.   

In lieu of flowers and gifts, please consider a donation to Wayside House, 378 NE 6th Ave, Delray Beach FL 33483, www.waysidehouse.net. They are a small, local organization providing quality services to women in need. We've donated many of Colleen's clothes and other personal belongings to them as well.
August 30, 2019
August 30, 2019
Sending all my love to Colleen’s wonderful family. My heart is broken for all of you. I know the absence of someone so beautiful and loved so completely is unbearable. Growing up, and I’m sure still today, the McMahon’s home was our collective home too... and by “our” I mean Nativity’s Class of ‘82! It remains to this day the ONLY home I was ever allowed to sleep over... for Colleen’s Bday party. Years go by in a blink... seems like yesterday we played with Barbies in the front yard (got caught by Kevin w/ the Barbies smooching), ski bus & chasing cute EA boys, HS proms... and then life got so “busy.” Col’s “started” so many years before mine did with marriage and kids... and I’ll always regret not keeping in touch in our later years. Still - and I think this is true of our entire class - we share a bond that will never be broken. We laugh the same, have the same loves, priorities, work ethics, senses of humor, even mannerisms. We were SO blessed with the gift of Nativity that our parents gave us. Colleen will always be in our hearts and part of who we are - as will the entire McMahon clan. I believe Heaven is all around us, and she surely will be guiding us through our days and showing us the beauty in the world and the joy that can still be found.
 All my love and hugs. -Anne
August 28, 2019
August 28, 2019
Is there anything like when Colleen saw you and her face opened into this sincere million dollar smile, and you could feel how much she loved you? Like the sun came right out of her. And when Col listened to you talk about something that was bothering you it was like she was trying to hear your feelings in your words and she looked at you like she wanted to read your face so she could understand how you felt. She experienced everything so intensely.

Col was truly the tenderest of vittles, so open hearted. I remember when Snooper went missing the night before her wedding (was it right before?), calling his name out and searching in ditches with flashlights. Col loved that little dog. She was so worried. (Thank god we found him or the wedding may have had to have been postponed and it was the most fun wedding ever). Or the night she accidentally hit a rabbit on a dark road on the way to the Point and it was like the end of the world - she felt so bad for that damn rabbit. It took a while to convince her we shouldn’t go back for it.

When Col was excited or happy you knew it. She had lots of different laughs, including an outburst laugh (HA!), a giggly-conspiratorial-should-we-really-be-laughing-about-this-laugh (with a demure tuck of her chin). Even her voice -- so many modulations, really high or low or whispers or shouts (usually with a smack on your arm and a NO!) and all in the space of a 1 minute conversation. Or if you told her something really outrageous she would hit you and say no and walk away and walk back, “Are you Serious!” Col’s handwriting was epic. She was left handed but even for a lefty it was completely bonkers. Like it matched the cascade of her thoughts or something. It was all bubbly and catty-wompus.

Col was drop dead gorgeous but never believed it. The woman who did her hair on her wedding day said something like, “Colleen we could shave you bald and you would still look beautiful.” She looked like a princess bride and danced like a fiend that night. I remember lessons at Jack Greenen’s dance studio in high school but Col’s moves were all her. Unteachable. Unmatchable. They defied all dance-move naming conventions.

I wish we were dancing. Or getting ready to go dancing (with Emma again to SXSW!). Or that we were little kids playing Barbies in Col’s front yard under the big pine trees. Or laughing in the Nativity girls’ bathroom. Or ice-skating on Freemans Pond or at the Y. Col could do a sort of an axel jump, I think she taught herself? It was like a piston firing - an energy burst. Like when she kicked ass at whatever sport she happened to be playing on any given day. She would crush it. Or I wish we were on the dock while she lifeguarded, talking about whatever. Lying on some old beat-up towels. A warped paperback copy of one of her Tolkien books by her side. She would probably waitressing later that day at the Sword. One of us was probably heartbroken or in love.

I try and imagine Col now with the dogs -- all of them including Snooper, and the birds (Merlin on one shoulder and Mr. T on the other), and the cat, and probably that damn bunny. And she’s started a vet clinic in animal heaven and is getting ready to go dancing with everyone she loves that’s up there with her. I love you Col and miss you. I love you, too, McMahons and Dan, Jack and Emma. Thank you for sharing Colleen with all of us and surrounding her with love and care, her whole life.
August 28, 2019
August 28, 2019
Note from the chief development officer of Wayside House...(Brooke, thanks for recommending them)

Hi Daniel,

What a beautiful tribute to your wife; I feel as if I know her through all the remembrances and photos shared. She was obviously very special and these gifts in her memory will help so much. There is such a strong history here at Wayside House and we are happy that Colleen and her family & friends will now be a part of that.

I will send thank you notes to all of the people who donate and will send you a list of names and addresses so you can know that as well. We are also grateful for the donations of some of her personal items and look forward to meeting you.
August 27, 2019
August 27, 2019
From Heather Richardson...."Hi Tim - I wish I could say something to make you feel better, but I know I can't.  I am so so sad about Colleen. All I can think of is when we were in a tent on the canoe trip ('89) planning how our life would go. I can see her beautiful eyes and big smile anytime I think of her. Colleen had a charm that made you feel like you were the only one in the room. I also know she was such a rock and best friend to my sister. Sending you and your family all my love.  She was an amazing person, and I know how hard she battled. ððð Heather (Austin) Richardson "
August 27, 2019
August 27, 2019
To the mcmahon family, the few times we were in Colleen's company, our memory will be of her sweet smile. Maryanne and Patrick kennedy
August 27, 2019
August 27, 2019
I am so sorry to hear this news. When I think of Colleen, I always think of her big smile and infectious laugh. Uncle T, Aunt Diane, Kev, Tim, Erin - my heartfelt condolences during this very trying time.
August 27, 2019
August 27, 2019
Colleen was a free spirit who enjoyed life and people. She had a smile that could melt the sternest heart and a bubbly personality that made people instantly feel attracted to her.  She grew up playing with our girls and although we didn’t see much of her when she married and moved to Florida, she always had a big hug for us when we did see her. 
God must have needed another angel and decided Colleen was the one He needed. She is now welcoming others with her big smile and making them feel at home. Colleen, you will be missed but live on in our hearts. Our love to the entire McMahon/Coate family. Harris & Vicky Wienke
August 27, 2019
August 27, 2019
From Steve Higgins........
What a beautiful woman. I'm just absolutely heartbroken. She was a gift from God to us all. An amazing, caring and energetic person.
I love you so much
Higgs
August 27, 2019
August 27, 2019
We spent an incredible hour with Colleen yesterday in Florida. She looked so beautiful and at peace. We wet the floor around her with tears of sorrow. We spoke of her preciousness, her fighting spirit and strength, and her absolute beauty both inside and out. She was a special presence and will continue to be. We are all better for having been touched by her.
August 26, 2019
August 26, 2019
Colleen sat in the first row, first seat in my AP English class. That was right where she belonged! I loved her because she was a brilliant student, and I loved her because she was such an interesting, warm, and wonderful young woman. We got to know each other, and I will never forget her:

My husband died young, at 48. T, her father, helped me through that time. Thank you! Not sure how I can help you now. 
Let me know. I owe you!!!

Love, Linda
August 26, 2019
August 26, 2019
Aunt Dianne, Uncle T, Kevin, Tim & Erin,

I am really sorry to hear about Colleen. My mom always kept us up to speed on all the McMahon's and I will keep you, Dan and the kids in my thoughts and prayers. I'll remember Colleen fondly. With love, Patrick Long
August 26, 2019
August 26, 2019
Dan, my longtime friend, I never had the pleasure of meeting your wonderful Colleen. However, the remembrance of dinner with you and Emma in Pittsburgh when Emma was just starting her college career at the University of Pittsburgh keeps flooding back. Through your beautiful, articulate, intelligent and thoughtful daughter, I could see the amazing combination of you and your wife. As we Orthodox Christians say, may the memory of Colleen be eternal.
August 26, 2019
August 26, 2019
To all of the Coates and all the "Buffalo McMahons": Debra and I have no words that can comfort you, just our love and gratitude for Colleen and her life. I cannot imagine your grief right now. But as I read Tim's stories I almost envy the joy of your memories with her. Prayers for all of you and for your "badass" wife, mother, daughter, sister, Colleen. 
August 26, 2019
August 26, 2019
Colleen was part of our team and family at Stevens Animal Hospital and she touched each one of us deeply, leaving her legacy and love with us forever. We will miss her deeply. Dan, our hearts go out to you and your family in this time of loss. Please let us know if you need anything now and in the future. 
August 26, 2019
August 26, 2019
Our hearts ache. Met many people in our lives, but no one more warm and gracious than Colleen, who was always willing to extend a helping hand. The world is worse off without her big and uplifting smile which is how we will remember her. The Sharp Family
August 26, 2019
August 26, 2019
Dan, my deepest and most heartfelt condolences to you and your family during this sad time. I am happy to have gotten the chance to meet Colleen, and will remember her kind and upbeat spirit. I know how much she meant to you and I wish you lots of love and support during your time of healing.
Page 2 of 2

Leave a Tribute

Light a Candle
Lay a Flower
Leave a Note
 
Recent Tributes
November 28, 2023
November 28, 2023
Happy 55th birthday. It's a hard day but a good day as I've spent it thinking of you and how much joy you brought to our family. I awoke thismmorning thinking of you as a precious little girl. Your picture in the NYC subway, in you camel coat is my favorite as it reminds me of what a good looking teen you would beccome. There are so many things I wish I had told you and it breaks my heart that I didn't get to say them. I'm trying to be good so I can tell you them when I meet you in heaven.Miss you alot!!
Love, Dad
November 28, 2023
November 28, 2023
Happy Birthday, Col! Thinking about your smile (you use your whole face to smile!) and sending love and giant hugs out to you and your family.
August 22, 2023
August 22, 2023
Love and miss you, Col! Thought of you everyday at the Point this summer -- seeing the cornflowers and Queen Anne's Lace and daisies, the bats, and the stars - and especially talking with your mom and dad in the garage. Thank you for all of the love you gave all of us. Any one of your friends could have told you anything and you would have listened without judgement and with tons of compassion. I miss your giant heart and am sending giant waves of appreciation to you and also to your parents who shared you with all of us.
Her Life

T's Eulogy from the 10/12 Funeral Mass

October 19, 2019
A Message from Colleen,
Thank you to all who have traveled far to comfort my family and friends. For being in this special place with my family who loved me for 50 years! You are carrying on MY tradition of trying to make people happy.

God wanted my parents and siblings to know that I was special so I was sent down by God to earth on Thanksgiving Day , November 28, 1968 and this year Thanksgiving Day is also on November 28 and I hope you will remember me on that day.

I’m sorry that I didn’t get to say goodbye when God called me home .

Dan you were the love of my life. Jack and Emma you were always my pride and joy and I hope you felt it. Erin, Tim , Kevin , Mom and Dad thank you for loving me unconditionally for my 50 years. Thank you Kevin for being the best brother and doctor who always answered my calls and worked hard to keep me healthy.Thank you Tim for being the best brother who guided me to St Lawrence and who gave me my last kiss. Thank you Erin for being a great younger sister. Our last lunch together in Ft Lauderdale meant the world to me. Thank you Mom for always coming to Ft Lauderdale when I needed you! Dry your tears and remember God’s plan was that we were TOGETHER at the lake for our last fourth of July this year.

My suffering has ended. The angels have led me into paradise. The God I learned about in this very church has been merciful and has forgiven my sins. I am at peace with the Lord. I’m dancing with the angels. I’m with Grandpa & Grandma McMahon, with Poppy and Nana. My great uncles Mike, Joe, Tommy, and Andy and great aunts Nel, Jean, Dotty, Rita and Betty are here. Ruth Coate, Amy Fazi and Leo Noe are together with us. And of course I think I see Snooper from time to time. Trust in God. I’m here waiting for you all. When you think of me, follow my example and try to make people happy.Remember that God is holding me in the palm of His hand until we are together again.

Jack's Eulogy of his Mom 9/7/19

September 23, 2019
To Live is to Fly: a remembrance of my mother, Colleen Coate

I wish that this were not happening, It feels wrong and it feels unfair to be here, speaking at my mother’s memorial service, before her 51st birthday. Her story deserved more chapters, and she deserved a different ending.

Mom dealt with numerous challenges in her life. Many of which I have only come to understand these past several years: depression, mental illness, addiction, codependency, physical challenges, and trauma to name a few. Immensely burdensome and taxing weights to bear. Colleen grappled these weights until the end with the stalwart perseverance of a migratory bird. After all, mom flew as she lived. Her feathers repeatedly broken and tattered. Her spirit dampened by the scale of the journey. Her body worn by the plight of an endless migration. Time after time, my beautiful and resilient mother pushed back the physical, mental, and emotional demons that sought to ground her. Colleen persevered by leaning on her flock, this beautiful flock of individuals here today, and she did so by never giving up. Even in her darkest hour I always knew that Collen Coate was fighting back.

This past year has been a triumph in so many ways. A highlight of my summer came was attending mom’s one year of sobriety meeting with her home group, the “Chica Girls”, and with my Dad. On that early June morning, in a municipal-esque yet quaint room, I listened to perhaps the most thoughtful and intensely vulnerable reflection of a human life that I have ever herd. That reflection was delivered by my mother, Colleen. With remarkable poise she recalled her life, from childhood through the present, leaving no stone unturned, and instigating teary eyes in more than a few audience members. Colleen bore herself on that day, displaying a profound level of introspective awareness and maturity. After mom finished speaking, an outpouring of love, empathy, and respect echoed through the crowd of roughly sixty. Several people saying that for instance, ‘they hadn’t wanted to drag themselves out of bed for that morning’s meeting, but that they were so glad that they did. Colleen’s speech made it all worthwhile.’ Who knows how many lives were changed, even saved, on that day. That memory, one of countless made with mom, will forever live on in me and in all who were there.

I am infinitely proud to be Colleen Coate’s son. I can’t fathom the person I would be today without Colleen as my mother. I do know, that I wouldn’t be the same, not even close, without the endless love and selfless devotion she showed Emma and me as children: without living, laughing, growing, traveling, and crying together. Directly or indirectly, Colleen Coate lives on in each and everyone here today. My mom is, was, and will always be an inextinguishable light to me and to all those she wrapped her wings around. An amazingly selfless, loving, and compassionate mother who put her family and those around her first. An inspiring woman, through whom I find courage, empathy, and inspiration.

I remember an email that my mom shared with the family after the passing of my great grandfather, Poppy, a few years ago. In the message, she attributed the following words to Poppy and the way he lived.

Live simply. Love generously. Care deeply. Speak Kindly.

I will always remember my mom by these mantras as I do Poppy. She held them close as close as she held Poppy’s picture on the desk in her room. Although her life was anything but simple, Colleen wished simplicity for those around her. She radiated love, generosity and kindness. Let us all hold each other close, support each other, learn from each other, respect each other, and not back down from our fights as Colleen did not back down from hers.

I love you Mom.
I will always love you,
your loving son, Jack.

Emma's Eulogy of her Mom 9/7/19

September 23, 2019
Thank you all for coming out to celebrate my mom. It’s been a gift to hear your stories, to share in your memories. You ask anyone in this room to describe Colleen and first and foremost will be her laugh, her smile, how she gave so much of herself to everyone she met.

One of my favorite memories of my mom is that of her reading the Lord of the Rings to Jack and myself, sharing with us this work of literature she loved so much. Her passing got me thinking of a quote from it: the hobbit Frodo Baggins says to the wizard Gandalf “I wish the Ring had never come to me. I wish none of this had happened.” Gandalf the wizard replies, “So do all who live to see such times, but that is not for them to decide. All we have to decide is what to do with the time that is given to us.” Looking out at all of you out today, I am reminded of what my mom did with the time she was given. She lived a life full of joy and warmth and love.

These last years, she lived less of that joy than she deserved. But, before all things she was a fighter. Through all of it, physical illness and her struggle for mental health, she fought. She struggled. We all did. But I take solace that over the past year, that struggle was paying off and she was winning, more and more. Jack and my dad had the honor of attending a ceremony to mark her 12th month sober this past June, and I remember speaking with her after the fact. I remember the fierceness of the pride I felt for her in that moment, and how grateful I was to share in her victory. That was the best gift she could have given me.

But I’ve been mourning the past often, these few weeks. Worrying about the future. Thinking about all the experiences I wanted to share with my mom. Regretting the opportunities I’d missed.But all we have to decide is what to do with the time given to us.

And with the time given to me, I choose to do my level best to live a life my mom wanted for me, filled with joy and boldness and dogged perseverance. In this way, I will take my mom with me for the rest of my life.
I guess that’s my takeaway for all of you here today: get out there. Honor Colleen’s memory by finding the joy in your life that she would have wanted for you.

Thank you all.
Recent stories

One Year

August 21, 2020
Today is the one year anniversary of Colleen’s death. Jack and I still talk about her, think about her, and talk with her every day. Death ends a person’s life on Earth, but not your relationship with that person. Our relationship with Colleen continues to develop and gain new richness, significance, spirituality, and the many different qualities of the transformative power of love. We continue to learn the important lessons and truths that Colleen’s life had to teach us, and that the next generations will need to know through passing along her memory.

Summer

August 1, 2020
Dear Coates and McMahons. Been thinking about Colleen lots these days. Summer was her season. Queen Anne's Lace and daisies, raspberries, lake water, cut grass, reading on the dock, kicking off a waterski. I wish we had her for longer. Sending lots and lots of love to you and to her. She feels nearby. Maybe she is orbiting closer to us right now?

Thinking about Col and sending love

December 5, 2019
I'm not sure if it's because it was just her birthday - or because it's the holiday season but I've been thinking about Col a lot these days. I've also been having dreams about her or dreams where she just shows up (: This isn't so much a story but a message to all of you who love Col, especially the McMahons and Coates, that that I love you and am thinking about you. It still doesn't feel real. Sincerely, Kristine

Invite others to Colleen's website:

Invite by email

Post to your timeline