This article ran in the Courier-Journal on June 15, 2020.
https://www.courier-journal.com/story/sports/2020/06/15/how-paul-schmitt-helped-grow-louisvilles-pool-minority-referees/3190816001/Louisville’s most influential referee was a whistleblower renowned for his restraint.
Paul Schmitt, who died Friday at age 82, coupled keen eyes with a judicious application of football’s rules. In more than half a century as an on-field official, observer and replay official, he practiced what Conference USA officials supervisor Gerald Austin abbreviates as “CFS.”
Common Football Sense.
“Not all officials have that,” Austin said Monday. “They may know the rules. They may know what a foul is and what a foul isn’t, but one thing that I thought Paul and I were on the same page on in teaching young officials was that there’s a lot of fouls out there that may not impact the game.
“What’s going to determine whether you’re a good official or not is being able to discern between what should be called and what shouldn’t be called. Paul had a very good feel for that.”
An official’s ability to distinguish between the important and the irrelevant can keep a game moving or turn it into a tedious, penalty-plagued grind. Paul Schmitt was a man who knew what mattered.
Following a 1955 facial injury as a senior at Flaget High School, he earned the distinction of being the first football player in the state of Kentucky to wear a facemask and would later earn a varsity letter as a lineman for Frank Camp at the University of Louisville.
But Schmitt’s more lasting mark was made after a controversial call by an all-white crew prompted a brawl and allegations of racial bias following Trinity’s 3-0 victory over Male in 1970.
Then president of the Kentuckiana Football Officials Association, Schmitt enlisted former U of L teammate Lenny Lyles to launch an initiative to expand Louisville's pool of minority officials. Karl Schmitt, president of the Louisville Sports Commission, says his older brother crashed a meeting of African American officials who were considering forming an independent association and was able to prevail upon them to remain underneath the association's umbrella.
“I think he might have been blind to color; he just knew good officials,” said John McGrath, a Schmitt disciple who served as head linesman in Super Bowl XLIV between the New Orleans Saints and Indianapolis Colts. “The amount of people that he’s had a direct influence on, it’s unheard of.”
Founder of the Southern Independent Collegiate Officiating Association, Schmitt’s recruits included Al Riveron, now the NFL’s vice president of officials. Riveron referred to Schmitt Monday as a “father figure in many ways.”
“He just saw me work a scrimmage and offered me a job after that,” he said. “He gave a lot of us an opportunity.”
Sarah Thomas, the NFL’s first full-time female official, worked her first game in Conference USA with Schmitt in attendance as the league’s designated observer.
"Paul had such a grace about him when I first met him," Thomas said. "You just knew that he had my best interests (at heart) in the world of officiating regardless of my gender.
"... I wouldn’t say he embraced me. He just accepted me as an official. Paul treated me like he treated every other rookie. It was just such a blessing to me to have someone of Paul's caliber, his stature, his reputation to accept me and tell me what I did right, but also to constructively criticize me to grow me as an official from Day One."
Schmitt’s own officiating career included a point-blank view of the famous Hail Mary touchdown pass Doug Flutie threw for Boston College against Miami in 1984. According to Karl Schmitt, it later fell to his brother to inform Oklahoma’s suspended Brian Bosworth that he was not permitted to participate in the ceremonial coin flip preceding the 1987 Orange Bowl.
“He had a way of basically seeing everything,” said C-USA official Maurice Pierre “To this day, I don’t know how he did it.
“After one particular scrimmage, where he was coming out to evaluate us, he comes in and tells everybody you did a good job. Then he gets to me. ‘Mo, you did a good job. But you’re kind of stiff out there. ... You’re lacking some swag.’ He’s 70-something at this point. What the hell does he know about swag?”
On reflection, Pierre conceded that his work was then, “way too technical, like a robot.” Henceforth, he intends to heed Paul Schmitt’s advice.
“Consider it noted,” Pierre said. “I’m going to swag it up from here on.”